Search Reports:

Login Form  

H.W. Mailing Lists  

Enter your e-mail to join the H.W. community mailing list, and get involved.   Learn More

--- or ---

Enter your e-mail to join the H.W. notifications only list for just official announcements. This is a very low traffic mailing list.

Top 100 Stories  

Cure Hypothyroidism
Chewing Gum
Amish and Autism
Brown Recluse Spiders
Eliminating Parasites
Antacids
Gallstones
Remedy Scabies
Ignore Dentists
Gardasil Whistle Blower
Budwig Regimen
pH Food Chart
Silica Supplements
Natural Stimulants
Colloidal Silver
Curing Milia
The Cancer Report
Iodine Supplementation
Treating Depression
M.M.S. Fraud
Body pH
Eliminate Shingles
Disposable Diapers
Subway Shame
hCG Diet Scam
Soy Dangers
S.S.R.I. Drugs
Curing Celiac Disease
Cure Autism
Curing Ulcers
Best Supplements
Copper Lotion
Air Fresheners
Dieting Right
Dr. Andrew Weil
Michael J. Fox
MSG and Taurine
Consumer Lab
Bee Stings
Curing Allergies
Rancid Oils
Vaccine Ingredients
Heart Disease
Forbidden Fruits
Foot Cleanses
Bell's Palsy
Hormone Regulator
Migraine Headaches
Zinc Supplements
Chlorophyll Supplementation
Table Salt
Niacin Supplements
Eliminating Fleas
Canola Oil
The Green Drink
Eye Drops
Everyone Has A.D.D.
Cleansing
Jim Humble Debate
Audio Archive
Decaffeinated Drinks
Medical Quotations
Poisonous Plastics
Ear Aches
Erectile Dysfunction
Forced Experiments
Swine Flu
Modified Foods
Curing Diabetes
Toxic Tampons
Kentucky Fried Chicken
God's Nutrition
Monsanto Killing Bees
Activated Carbon
Corruption At WikiAnswers
Low Platelet Counts
Chemical Fertilizers
Sodium Benzoate
Cayenne Pepper
ACS: Cancers Heal
Fire Safe Cigarettes
Treating Epilepsy
Sunscreen Lies
Dangerous Light Bulbs
PLU numbers
Non-Stick Cookware
DCA Fraud
Treating Hepatitis
Lung Infections
Dangerous Deodorants
Spray Tanning
Quickly Shift Body pH
Hand Sanitizers
So Evil
Whole Foods Market
Remedy Food Poisoning
Cluster Headaches
Radioactive Foods
Video: Obamacare
Mike Adams

F.D.A. Blocked Suicide Warning for Anti-Depressants

Written by Print  E-mail

Selective Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitor anti-depressants (S.S.R.I.'s) hit the market in 1988.  Immediately, reports of intense suicidal thoughts and actions while taking these drugs began to flood into the F.D.A..  Despite the reports, and data indicating a higher rate of suicides from those using the drugs than from those using placebos, it took about twenty years for the F.D.A. to issue a warning about the risk.

The warning was considered a victory to many who had lost loved ones to S.S.R.I. drugs.  Public perception was that the F.D.A. had stood up to Big Pharma and forced reluctant S.S.R.I. manufacturers to issue an appropriate warning.  Thereby, solidifying the perception of the F.D.A.'s role as advocate for the public.

However, this perception has been shattered by a recent federal court ruling that exposed a dirty little secret that the F.D.A. likely hoped would never come to light.  In Dobbs v. Wyeth Pharms., the court determined that the F.D.A. repeatedly prevented at least one S.S.R.I. manufacturer from issuing a suicide-related warning for fear that it might "reduce the use of anti-depressants and thereby undermine the benefit of their use in treating depression."

The ruling stems from a lawsuit brought by the widow of a man who was believed to have committed suicide as a result of taking Effexor.  The lawsuit accused Wyeth Pharmaceuticals of failing to properly warn patients that Effexor may increase the risk of suicide.

In its defense, Wyeth presented evidence that it had, on three separate occasions, attempted to institute a more "extensive suicide warning", but the F.D.A. had refused to approve each proposed warning.

Wyeth's first attempt occurred on September 25, 2002, when it submitted to the F.D.A. the results of seven Effexor pediatric studies, accompanied by a proposed label alteration describing the rate of suicidality events for children.  The F.D.A. rejected Wyeth's proposed label alteration, which would have warned parents of the risk to their children, and then it directed Wyeth to only add the label change proposed by the F.D.A.. The F.D.A. added, "we do not feel that it would be useful to describe these negative trials in labeling, since this may be misinterpreted as evidence that [Effexor] does not work in this population."

The second attempt occurred in August 2003, when Wyeth amended its product label to caution patients about increased reports of "suicide related adverse events such as suicidal ideation and self harm" in pediatric patients.

The F.D.A. ordered Wyeth to remove the language included in the enhanced label warning and to substitute F.D.A. language that was applicable to all S.S.R.I.'s at that time.  According to the F.D.A., it did so because it did "not believe that a causal association has yet been definitively established."  Never mind that Wyeth's own internal studies (from the manufacturer) indicated sufficient cause for a warning.

Undeterred, Wyeth made a third and final attempt to include a warning about suicide on its drug label.  It revised the language contained within its warning, and asked the F.D.A. to allow Effexor's label to continue to include a pediatric precaution.

On May 13, 2004, the F.D.A. ordered the removal of Wyeth's warning.  By that time, the F.D.A. had finally admitted that sufficient evidence existed to support a warning about medically-induced suicides, but it required that Wyeth, and all other S.S.R.I. manufacturers adopt the specific language dictated by the F.D.A. rather than use the warnings proposed by the manufacturers.

The whole affair was managed like a public relations campaign, whereby the F.D.A. was presented as the organization leading the charge for labeling that would protect children; when in fact, it was actually the agency that had always suppressed such information, while essentially operating a protection racket for select pharmaceutical companies for roughly 20 years.

Other S.S.R.I. manufacturers have attempted to escape liability by arguing that the F.D.A. would not have permitted them to issue suicide warnings prior to 2004.  However, those claims ultimately failed because the manufacturers could not establish that they had made any effort to issue a warning.  Wyeth is the first to conclusively prove that the F.D.A. blocked a proposed warning.

As a result, the federal court dismissed the failure to warn claim against Wyeth.  However, the case was permitted to proceed, due to additional claims.

Whose Side is the F.D.A. On?

To Wyeth's credit, it is the only S.S.R.I. manufacturer to propose a suicide warning prior to the issuance of the Black Box warning in 2004.  Wyeth is also the only S.S.R.I. manufacturer to list "homicidal ideation" as an adverse event on its product label.  All other S.S.R.I. manufacturers are vehemently opposed to the issuance of such warnings.

By rejecting Wyeth's proposed warning, the F.D.A. was serving the interests of the other S.S.R.I. manufacturers.  Had Wyeth succeeded in issuing a warning for Effexor, other S.S.R.I. manufacturers would have been forced to follow suit.

The F.D.A.'s purported concern that the warning "may be misinterpreted as evidence that [Effexor] does not work in [children]" was nothing more than a smoke screen.  S.S.R.I.'s have never been approved for, nor shown to be any more effective than placebos in treating children, with the exception of Prozac.  (Prozac's effectiveness is only slightly above that of placebos.)  However, despite these facts, millions of children continue to be prescribed S.S.R.I. drugs "off label."

The F.D.A was not so concerned about the public misinterpreting the lack of efficacy within this class of drugs, as it was with the public discovering their lack of efficacy.

The primary concern for S.S.R.I. manufacturers, and F.D.A. officials with financial ties to S.S.R.I. manufacturers, was the effect that an honest suicide warning would have had on pediatric prescription rates.  Fewer children being prescribed S.S.R.I.'s would have meant less profits for the drug companies, and less lucrative drug approvals.

As it turns out, the F.D.A.'s fears were prophetic.  According to a Medco analysis, the rate of children who received anti-depressant prescriptions fell about 16% in the months following the issuance of the Black Box warning.

In the end, the F.D.A. saved S.S.R.I. manufacturers millions, if not billions of dollars by delaying the issuance of a suicide warning.  It also cost countless children their lives.

When it comes to S.S.R.I.'s, the F.D.A. has repeatedly chosen Big Pharma interests over the safety of the public; profits over people.

Perhaps the most ironic and heartbreaking aspect of the story is that parents who had lost their children to S.S.R.I.'s actually broke down in tears, and thanked F.D.A. officials for issuing the F.D.A. Black Box warning in 2004.

Well orchestrated, indeed.

Sources:

Dobbs v. Wyeth Pharms., 2011 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 79140 (case no. CIV-04-1762-F)

Medco Report: Pediatric Antidepressant Use Shows Substantial Decline Over Past Year

Effexor Drug Label

Related Articles:

The gunman was described as a loner and was being treated by a psychiatrist for...

Antidepressants Produce Plenty of Side-Effects, But Don't Reduce Depression

Sharp Rise in U.S. Military Psychiatric Drug Use and Suicides

The Pharmaceutical Tragedy of Kurt Danysh

Antidepressant Intoxication Legal Defenses

 


Kurt Danysh is a trained legal investigator.  In 2005, he founded The S.A.V.E. Project, which works to expose the harmful effects of anti-depressants (www.thesaveproject.com). We reported of Kurt's personal story in the article, The Pharmaceutical Tragedy of Kurt Danysh, and he is also featured in our upcoming documentary, Prescription For Manslaughter.


 

Comments (7)
  • Marcia Kirschbaum  - Incredible

    I don't find this article surprising in the least, but that doesn’t help me understand why we still have this bought and paid for organization calling the shots. Meanwhile, how many thousands are incarcerated for smoking a joint? Incredible, how apathetic and/or ignorant our society is.

  • john

    we should all know by now that all of these mood effecting and enhancing drugs, are not there to help anyone! they were developed and handed out like candy to all who complain to thier doctor as population dumbing drugs to turn the people into docile sheeple who do not question anything!!
    these drugs have been in the works since the days of adolf hitler and operation paperclip.
    stop drinking the florinated& cloranated water.
    if you want to remain in your own mind, stay away from the doctors who PRACTICE medicin(sorcery or witch craft) haven't you noticed how they never cure anything they just treat the symptoms with man made petro chemical drugs??? when was the last time your doctor suggested a herb or natural substance to help you ??? GOD created everything we need to heal ourselves and it all exists in HIS created nature!!!
    if your depressed try picking up HIS HOLY WORD the bible and reading it!!! this is a sure cure for depression, because in the end ALL who except HIS only begoten SON JESUS THE CHRIST, WIN BIG!!!!!!! amen and may GOD help all who are lost and depressed, if it is in HIS WILL!!!

  • cee cee  - Thank You Kurt For All You Do To Bring Awareness!

    I hope that all readers come to know how hard Kurt works to inform us all and to give us a window into the world of SSRI's.

  • Karen Copeland  - Land of the Free - Free if you murder under the FD

    What I really, REALLY want to know is Why are they still there? Living well, driving fancy cars, eating in top restaurants on nights and weekends and arranging for sick people to die during the week. And they do it with impunity.
    Land of the Free? Really!

  • cynthia cecile lee

    after nearly 15 years on one antidepressant after another...that not only did not help, but made me worse..I took my own life back into my hands and slowly and carefully weaned myself off them. BUT now before my life was a total and complete shambles.
    I had lost my home job and marriage ...all while being medicated with several mood altering drugs...actually personality altering really. Prozak will one day go down as the big health hazzard and indeed perhaps one of the leading causes of death?
    For me...I was a different person...and i knew it...but on top of that my physical health suffered greatly as well.
    and so finally I was changed over to Cymbalta which further deteriorated my health.
    *8months ago I took back my life.
    every day I'm getting stronger..and becoming more like the person I was before this all started...which by the way was because of another medical mistake. I had undergone bi-lateral mastectomies because of breast cancer, during the surgury a piece of gauze and numerous titanium clips were left behind...I had months of pain and several operations before they found out why I was not healing ...my story is so long I just can't go in to it...but it just went from bad to worse.
    Today I live alone, and will most likely stay alone. But this took my husband and the life and career we had together...
    I'm tired of living with the mistakes of the medical profession. But I guess it's better then dying from them

  • lisa

    Cynthia,
    I'm happy to read that you are taking your life back and I hope you are in good health. Blessings to you. Your testimony will help others weigh the risks before choosing to use the medical industry. Thank you for the article Kurt.
    Lisa

  • Charleen

    My husband took his own life while on effixor. I also blame the doctor for prescribing it without any real reason for it and did not explain to my husband what he was prescribing, side effects or even book a follow up appointment


Only members may write comments.

Get the Book!  

Hardback version of Defy Your Doctor and Be Healed
Our book, Defy Your Doctor and Be Healed, is available now. Learn more or preview it.

Ask Thomas and Sarah  

Thomas and Sarah from Health Wyze Media A new feature! Ask your questions and we'll respond.

Ask Now!

Newest Audio Show  

Episode 34

Advertisements  

Health Wyze Colloidal Copper Lotion

The Health Wyze Antiperspirant